
Where would Israel be today, if the world had let Hitler and the Germans do what they pleased with the Warsaw ghetto, with the death camps? Germany was a democratically elected government—should we have stepped back from the horror of their inhumane treatment of the Poles just because they had a democracy? Does the suffering that the Jewish peoples endured in the 40's give them carte blanche for war crimes now? Why is it different, when the treatment is the same, but only the names have changed?
Evil endures. It wears different masks. The atrocity we stamped out in one generation recurs in the next. It seldom recurs in the same way. Yes, the Jewish peoples suffered massively in WWII. (They weren't the only ones, ask the Romany, ask the Russians, ask the French and the Belgians). Obviously, people who have suffered so much would not repeat the evil that they lived through at another's hands, would they?
And yet, modern science and psychology bears this out. Victims of violence often become perpetrators of the same. Without treatment, violent crimes are perpetuated through the generations, repeated upon new innocents. This is Israel's condition today. Israel was a nation founded by shell-shocked sufferers of PTSD. They didn't get treatment, they went to war again, this time against the indigenous peoples of Palestine, and it continues to this day. Should we let the innocents of Palestine suffer? Why do we let the world's largest ghetto, the largest open air prison, continue to exist? For this is certainly what Gaza is, Warsaw revisited. Why do we let the obviously traumatized Israelis continue to perpetrate violent acts of aggression against children, for Christ's sake! For there are children in Gaza, there are mothers there, and fathers, and all they want is what anyone wants, a chance for life, a chance for family, and ways and means to feed and keep them.
The blockade of Gaza is illegal, it is immoral, it is evil at it's shape-shifting best, all dressed up in fancy words and self-righteous indignation. Just because the Jewish people suffered in the 40's does not give them a right to turn around and give out a 'healthy dose' of the same. It certainly does not give them a right to board a boat in international waters, guns blazing, to kill peaceful peoples, who only were doing what they did for the Jews in WWII, trying to stop the madness, trying to stop the blockade, and to give humanitarian aid to distressed peoples.
What if the world had sat back and let Germany have its way? Think about it. But, the world did not sit back then, and we should not sit back now. Evil still wages war, it has patriotic words, and massive PR machines, and plenty of reasons to justify its actions. But its nature has not changed, and we are still fighting the same battle. However, we can't use the weapons of evil to win the war, or we face becoming what we fight.
The Turkish people who died on that convoy are heroes. As are the rest of the international crew. And the Israeli soldiers who opened fire on peaceful people are still war criminals and evil-doers, pawns or no. We can no longer stand back and let this continue. We didn't let Hitler's Germany get away with its treatment of Warsaw, and we cannot let Israel do the same to Gaza. Keep up the work, keep up the talk, keep trying to break the blockade. Write, talk, act, contact your representatives, make them listen. Vote, vote with your political choice, vote with your collective currency. Don't support the war machine, don't support politicians who stand back and do nothing, don't support the evil that is the Gaza blockade. Don't buy Israeli products until they lift the blockade. These are the peaceful choices we have, we who live too far from the conflict to try to cross the blockade. But we must make this choice, for the sake of the world, and for the sake of our children, everywhere.
In quantum peace.
5 comments:
Thank you.
None are so blind as those who will not see.The first boat had activist that were prepared to cause a confrontation and the Israelis fell into the trap.The other 2 boats were peacefully boarded and the people were released unharmed.It is very telling that when other countries have forcefully killed and expelled untold millions of inhabitants the UN is deafening silent.So save me your crocodile tears for a group of people that "Hate the Jews more than they Love their Children"
None so craven as those who publish anonymously. The Israelis 'fell into the trap?' With unarmed folks? Really? They came in with guns blazing, and then complained because several brave people disarmed the armed? And then those poor troops were so unnerved as to shoot several unarmed activists execution style in the back of the head? This is a trap, all right, but methinks it is the Israeli's trap for the activists.
Please provide links for your contention that the UN is silent during genocide and forced expatriation. I would be happy to know the conditions. I do know that the UN has forcefully condemned Israel's treatment of both the Palestinians and their political prisoners, and that political Israel, as usual, blithely ignores such condemnation—the hallmark of bullies everywhere.
The reason the next couple of boats were peacefully boarded is because all eyes were on Israel now. I hardly think they would like the same publicity, do you?
I also find it telling that Israel released their parody of the boarding and killings in short order. Such remorse (and empathy) is astounding.
Save me your propoganda, sir, and your slogans. 'Crocodile tears'. Really? http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TnHRwR5rhkQ
Remarkable how Israel has conveniently forgotten the lessons WWII taught. The victims have truly become the aggressors.
Anonymous # 3, as I have no way of distinguishing past your right to disguise yourselves in a public forum, I wish to state categorically that one of the problems in this area arises because one speaks of 'Israel' as the problem. Israel, per se, is not the problem. There are many peaceful Israelis just like there are many peaceful Palestinians, just like there are peaceful Germans and Poles, and Americans, and Mexicans, and you get my drift, yes? Peace is not mistakable for anything else.
I also want to state categorically that I heartily condemn those who insist upon their stale weapon solutions to their 'domestic problems'. There is no excuse for war. Lay down your arms. We are all humans on this bus, like it or not.
Post a Comment